Best of 2012, part 1

2012 is coming to an end, so what better time than right now to wrap up its music offerings and create yet another "best of" list which I'm sure the world is not lacking this time of year. While writing this, I am fully aware of the futility of such an effort: there's no way I have even heard all of the year's most significant songs and compositions. I am likely to discover many of them later. So the top 10 that follows cannot really be the final word on 2012 - only a list of the most impressive songs I have heard so far. Yet this is not to belittle the list, or say it has no significance: I have heard some pretty amazing pieces of music this year already.

Sigur Rós: Valtari

Before going any further, let's make one thing absolutely clear. Even though the name of the blog is ProgActive, what follows is not a collection of best progressive rock albums and songs. There are no genre limitations here. All that matters is the quality of the music, not where it may be pigeonholed. Obviously, I do lean considerably towards prog in my preferences, but am not limited only there.

Before getting to the songs themselves, a few words about the albums of 2012. Here at ProgActive we don't really celebrate them, although in some exceptional cases they may receive honorable mentions. I firmly believe that the way music is collected and listened to has already permanently changed. The album by a single artist or group is really no longer the defining unit when it comes to a collection of music. A playlist is. Even back in the early 1980's when I first started compiling  "year's best" lists (I think my first was in 1981, topped by The Garden by John Foxx), I was more interested in individual tracks than entire albums. There is even more reason for that now that the availability of digital downloads means that purchasing individual songs is more and more common as opposed to buying entire albums - be they in digital or physical format.

OSI: Fire Make Thunder

In spite of that, if we do have a brief look at 2012 albums next, there is one release that can easily be selected above all others. It is in fact the one and only new album I bought this year: the self-titled album by the American symphonic prog group Echolyn which I already reviewed back in August. It is a slightly uneven piece of work, but an impressive one nonetheless.

Many other album releases that I anxiously waited for in advance turned out to be disappointing. Anastasis, the first studio album by Dead Can Dance in 16 years, is one that comes to mind in particular: high expectations that were met by mediocre results. Anastasis is not bad, and it's certainly better than the group's previous two releases: the completely aimless Into the Labyrinth (1993) or the too ethnic for its own good Spiritchaser (1996), but that's all you can say for its defense. On the Dead Can Dance scale, Anastasis is still well below average.

In much the same way, two groups that had shown promise on their earlier releases, Anathema and OSI let me down with their new albums Weather Systems and Fire Make Thunder, respectively. And an even bigger letdown than these two was All the Wars by The Pineapple Thief, on which I failed to find anything truly interesting whatsoever. Considering the group's earlier masterworks, this came as a definite surprise. Compared to it, even Sounds That Can't Be Made by Marillion seemed satisfying: I expected next to nothing and got exactly what I expected.

Anathema: Weather Systems

Of course, 2012 albums included some pleasant surprises as well. Many better works came from artists that I wasn't paying particular attention to beforehand. For example, a year ago I had already more or less forgotten about the Icelandic group Sigur Rós, whose 2008 album with the unpronounceable title had been such a huge disappointment back when it came out that I didn't even bother to listen to their new album Valtari until several months after its release, only to realise that they had made a really, really impressive return to form.

Another album for which I had low expectations to begin with was the debut album of Storm Corrosion. This was due to Steven Wilson's apparent growing interest towards heavy metal. When he decided to collaborate with Mikael Åkerfeldt of Opeth, I assumed that they would produce some kind of a black prog metal album that would contain a lot of growling vocals and be of little interest to me. As it turned out, I was wrong, and pleasantly surprised. There are no metal riffs at all on Storm Corrosion the album. Instead, it contains some of this year's best musical moments, although it is a noticeably uneven piece of work, just like Echolyn.

One more Swedish artist worth mentioning is the goth / dark ambient group Arcana, whose latest album As Bright as a Thousand Suns was released under my radar, but which I luckily stumbled across a little later and found many good moments contained therein.

Next, we narrow down the scope of the actual top 10 of 2012. As before, I have eliminated really long songs from the list because, at least to me, they seem like an art form of their own. Already in the 1980's, I compiled a separate list for them, drawing the line to 10 minutes. This year, there haven't been too many candidates in the "longer than 10 minutes" category, so it is then Echolyn who dominate that list, with Storm Corrosion a close second.

Echolyn's brilliant Speaking in Lampblack (10 mins. 45 secs.) would be my very first recommendation, closely followed by Island (16 mins. 38 secs.) from the same album. It would be advisable to also check out Storm Corrosion's Ljudet innan (10 mins. 7 secs.) as well as their album's title track (10 mins. 2 secs.). But that's really all the really outstanding long tracks from 2012 I have been able to discover so far.

Following this, we finally move on to the top 10... due to be ready and published right here either tomorrow or, at latest, on Monday, New Year's Eve. Please be sure to come back and check out the finest tracks running under 10 minutes and released during 2012.